Strawberries & Cream Pie Jello Shots

A 2-in-1 boozy Strawberries and Cream Pie Jello Shots dessert that will satisfy your sweet tooth and give you a little kick! It’s perfect for strawberry lovers. 

This post may include affiliate links

Table of Contents

1. How to Make Strawberries and Cream Pie Jello Shots
2. Strawberries and Cream Pie Jello Shots Tips & Tricks
3. Strawberries & Cream Pie Jello Shots

Jello shots are one of my favorite ways to serve alcohol to a crowd. This recipe is super simple, can be prepared in advance, and they don’t take up too much room in your fridge—or on your serving table! 

Hi cousins! Ready to make this infused dessert? Let’s take a quick look at the history of Jello shots before we dive into the recipe. 

How to Make Strawberries and Cream Pie Jello Shots

Who Invented Jello Shots?

How, when, and who created Jello shots isn’t crystal clear. Gelatin has been around since the 1800s, and the Jello we know and love today peaked in popularity in the 1950s. Countless Jello recipes were created, both sweet and savory. An 1862 book (last reprinted in 2013), How to Mix Drinks, or The Bon Vivant’s Companion by Jerry Thomas featured an alcohol-infused punch jelly that is the Jello shot’s predecessor. Jello shots really took off in the 1950s when Musician, Scientist, and US Veteran Tom Lehrer found a sneaky way to bring alcohol to his naval base Christmas party—he added vodka to Jello and the modern Jello shot was invented! 

Ingredients

Pie Shell

• ¾ cup graham cracker crumbs—you can crush your own graham crackers, but it’s faster to just buy crumbs. 
• ¼ cup sugar—standard white sugar is best for this recipe.  
• 3 tbsp. butter melted—salted or unsalted, whichever you have in your fridge. 

Strawberry Filling

• 1 package of Strawberry Jello—I don’t know about you, but strawberry is one of my favorite Jello flavors!  
• 1 cup boiling water—boil on the stove or in the microwave, whichever is easier.  
• 1 cup strawberry pie filling—I use canned strawberry filling. Most cans have enough to double this recipe. You can freeze the leftover filling for up to 3 months. 
• ½ cup Strawberry cream liqueur—this gives your Jello shots a creamy texture. Chill your strawberry cream liqueur to speed up the setting time. 
• ½ cup Whipped Cream flavored Vodka—whipped cream vodka is lighter and sweeter than standard vodka. 
• Garnishes—garnish with whipped cream and sliced strawberries. 

Supplies

• Measuring cups
• Whisk
• Medium pot to boil water
• Medium mixing bowl 
• Mixing spoon 
• Disposable or reusable 2-ounce condiment cups
• Optional: cookie sheet to transfer in and out of the fridge, a decorative or tiered tray to display your shots, and toothpicks or tiny spoons to release the shots. 

Strawberries and Cream Pie Jello Shots Tips & Tricks

Pro Tip: use a mixing bowl with a spout so that it is easier to transfer the infused mixture into the shot cups. 

Chill Your Liqueur

Non-infused Jello recipes call for boiling water to dissolve the gelatin, and cold water to speed up the setting time. Since this recipe only has boiling water, you will need to chill the strawberry liqueur and whipped cream vodka. You can chill the strawberry pie filling too. 

Why The Graham Cracker Crust?

Most Jello shots are crustless, but I like to mix things up! This is a fusion of 3 fan favorites—a creamy strawberry pie, Jello, and alcohol. It’s a fun treat that you and your guests will enjoy. Always be mindful when consuming alcohol-infused desserts, as the alcohol can sneak up on you! 

You can still serve wine, beer, and other cocktails—but these shots give you an elevated and easy option that doubles as dessert. 

If you want, you can make it without the graham cracker crust, but I promise it’s worth the extra few minutes!  

What to Serve Your Strawberry and Cream Pie Jello Shots In?

I like to serve Jello shots in 2-ounce condiment cups that you can buy at the Dollar Tree! You can also purchase disposable or reusable condiment cups online. Disposable makes clean-up easier. And yes, you can find biodegradable condiment cups! 

You can also buy quick-release condiment cups, but they don’t work as well with the pie crust in this recipe. 

Prep On A Cookie Sheet or Serving Tray

This recipe makes 16 2-ounce Jello shots. I like to spread my condiment cups out on a cookie sheet or serving tray. This catches any spills when pouring your infused mixture into the condiment cups—which you are likely to have with the chunks of strawberry in the pie filling. 

Prepping your shots on a sheet pan also makes transferring them to the fridge fast and easy. 

Chill For 2 Hours

Even with their miniature size and chilling the liqueur beforehand, it will take 2 full hours for your shots to chill. Once chilled, pop the lids on (if you haven’t already) and stack your shots to maximize space in your fridge. 

Can I Make My Jello Shots in Advance?

Yes! Unlike most mixed drinks and infused party punch, this recipe can be made 3 to 5 days in advance. And, once chilled, they don’t take up as much room in your fridge as a punch bowl or pitcher. Stack in the fridge in a container, in a drawer, or on a shelf. 

Garnish Before Serving

You can serve these without garnishing, but I’m all about the presentation! You can pre-slice a few strawberries earlier in the day (or 3 to 4 days in advance, but the fresher the better). Store the slices in an airtight container. If the strawberries are small, you don’t need to slice them. 

Once you are ready to serve, garnish with whipped cream and strawberries. 

Serve Immediately

While the shots will stay good out of the fridge for a couple of hours, the whipped cream will melt—so serve ASAP. Most of your guests will want 2 or more, so feel free to double this recipe! 

How to Release Jello Shots From the Condiment Cups?

The best way to enjoy your Strawberry and Cream Pie Jello Shots is to have a balanced mix of Jello and the graham cracker crust. Squeezing the sides of the condiment cups will help to release the Jello. Make it easier for your guests by keeping toothpicks or small spoons on your serving table.

Just run the toothpick or spoon around the edges of the cup to release the Jello or use the spoon to spoon it out. Espresso spoons work great! 

Do you love Jello Shots & Cocktails? If so check out my Blue Malibu Breeze Jello Shot  and my Pink Moscato Lemonade !

Print this recipe, and be sure to share on Pinterest! Don’t forget to tag and follow me on Facebook, Instagram, and Pinterest, subscribe to I Heart Recipes on YouTube, and check out all my cookbooks!