A Sinfully Delicious Homemade Dutch Sweet Potato Pie with a Crumble Topping!
Last year I shared my recipe for my homemade soul food style sweet potato pie. Needless to say, y’all loved it! So many of you made, served, and loved the sweet potato pie during the holidays. Some of you even sent me several emails for more pie recipes for the holidays. Well, sweetie pies, I heard your requests, and I am here to answer them. This year I will be sharing several pie recipes!
In this post, I’m going to share my recipe for a homemade dutch sweet potato pie. This recipe right here, just might change your life! It is that freaking good! I recently served this pie at a family gathering and got plenty of praises! EVERYONE loved it. Some people were actually mad at me because I only made one pie (don’t ask me what I was thinking). Next time, I will make at least three for a family gathering.
The recipe below makes one pie. I used a store bought pie shell, but if you want to make a homemade buttery pie shell, I have a recipe available that you can use.
Okay y’all, enough of my yapping – let’s get to this darn pie!
(WARNING!! If you’re trying to lose weight, stay away from this pie!!! You will forget all about your diet!)
If you like this Dutch Sweet Potato Pie, try some of my other pie recipes!
I’m a Soul Food blogger living in the Pacific Northwest, bringing Southern cooking to gorgeous Seattle, Washington. I was born and raised in the PNW, but my family roots go all the way to Baton Rouge, Louisiana, where my grandparents were born and raised. I live every day to bring the traditional values, recipes, and love of food to life for my family—whether they’re online or in real life. So, welcome to the party, family!
Dutch topped pies are my husband’s favorite. This recipe is definitely a winner! We love all things sweet potato! This pie looks so delicious. Pinned. This will definitely be on our Thanksgiving menu. Thanks for sharing.
Hi Rosie! I love everything you make! The pie was awesome but I can’t get the crumb topping like your of course..could you please make a video so I can see the consistency of the topping? I just logged onto patreon and I didn’t see a video. Thanks so much and please keep posting!!!
Hi Dawn! This recipe doesn’t have a video. However, if you’re ever looking for my videos be sure to log onto my YouTube channel YouTube.com/iheartrecipes . Not Patreon. 🙂
Hi Rosie, would it make any difference if I use your soul food style sweet potato pie recipe and just add this crumble on top? Love your recipes, thanks for sharing!
Thanks for Sharing your recipes!! My husband and I loves sweet potato pie, or actually sweet potato anything!!! This looks awesome and I’m making it tonight. I love all your recipes and have fixed several of them. Some have gone into my cookbook that I am scrapbooking. So we thank you for your shares with such good recipes.
Keep them coming!!!!! 🙂
Looking forward to trying this for the husband, his request. I used to make a similar pie but can’t find the recipe. This looks amazing, can’t wait. Thanks!!!
[…] I actually have several pumpkin pie recipes, but my favorite one tastes just like a sweet potato pie!! I kid you not! This pumpkin pie tastes so much like a sweet potato pie, that I was able to fool, a few of my family and friends , into believing that it was a sweet potato pie! […]
Table of Contents
Sweet Potato pie is one of my favorites, and you added that buttery crumble top! I could eat that topping with a fork! 🙂
It’s amazing! You must try it!
I don’t think there is anything better than a pie with a streusel topping and this pie has a lot!!! Can’t wait to try it.
Yes! I love it!
I’ve never seen bourbon extract…I’ve seen rum but never bourbon. Do you know where I can buy it?
Yes, Trader Joes and Kroger stores carry it. You can use regular vanilla if you’d like as well.
Dutch topped pies are my husband’s favorite. This recipe is definitely a winner! We love all things sweet potato! This pie looks so delicious. Pinned. This will definitely be on our Thanksgiving menu. Thanks for sharing.
Hi Mary! Make sure that you make more than one pie, if you’re expecting a lot of guest. This pie goes fast! XOXO
Hi Rosie! I love everything you make! The pie was awesome but I can’t get the crumb topping like your of course..could you please make a video so I can see the consistency of the topping? I just logged onto patreon and I didn’t see a video. Thanks so much and please keep posting!!!
Hi Dawn! This recipe doesn’t have a video. However, if you’re ever looking for my videos be sure to log onto my YouTube channel YouTube.com/iheartrecipes . Not Patreon. 🙂
Hi Rosie, would it make any difference if I use your soul food style sweet potato pie recipe and just add this crumble on top? Love your recipes, thanks for sharing!
Hi Marcy! You can definitely do that! XOXO
This was delicious. I made it for my Thanksgiving dinner and enjoyed it so much. Thank you for sharing your delicious recipes.
Thanks for Sharing your recipes!! My husband and I loves sweet potato pie, or actually sweet potato anything!!! This looks awesome and I’m making it tonight. I love all your recipes and have fixed several of them. Some have gone into my cookbook that I am scrapbooking. So we thank you for your shares with such good recipes.
Keep them coming!!!!! 🙂
I have plenty more to come, stay tuned! XOXO
Hey love your recipes. I am putting together my menu for the holiday. I would love to know your choice for store bought pie crust. Thanks
Hi Telicia! I like Pillsbury 😀
Does it have to be covered when it goes in the oven
No, it doesn’t 🙂
can i use can sweet potato?
You can try it, but fresh is better.
Oh my you should do sweet potato cupcakes,loaf bread,or cake with a cream cheese frosting or marshmallow frosting
Looking forward to trying this for the husband, his request. I used to make a similar pie but can’t find the recipe. This looks amazing, can’t wait. Thanks!!!
Awesome!! Enjoy!
I absolutely loved this recipe!!!!! It’s a keeper!!!!
I made this pie last Thanksgiving. It was a big hit!! All the recipes that I’ve tried from iheartrecipes have turned out great.